Add your view: Hear'Say

Hear'Say: Is the CD great pop or just pap?

BBC News Online's Ian Youngs said Hear'Say's Popstars album will go to number one - but will they be a lasting success?

"If you are already a fan, then you are going to love it," he says.

"But Popstars will do nothing to persuade their critics that they are any more than just another harmless manufactured band - even if they can actually sing."

But what do you think?

Send us your review.