Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point
On Air
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Tuesday, June 9, 1998 Published at 21:43 GMT 22:43 UK


UK Politics

Education Bill 'bulldozed' through

Labour's frontbench education team: unmoved by dissenters

MPs have voted to back government plans to end student maintenance grants and replace them with loans.

The plans are laid out in the Teaching and Higher Education Bill, which controversially will also introduce £1,000-a-year tuition fees for most students.

The Third Reading of the Bill, which sparked a Labour backbench revolt on Monday night over the grants issue, was passed by 307 votes to 174, a government majority 133.


Phil Willis: "This bill is not about helping students..."
The Bill now returns to the Lords, where peers will have to consider whether to insist on three amendments on which they defeated the government but which were overturned in the Commons.

The rebellion late on Monday night was initiated by leftwing MPs, led by Tony Benn and Jeremy Corbyn, who felt the Bill would be a "tax on learning" and would jeopardise the principle of free education for those from less well-off families.

Campaigners, including pop stars and comedians, staged a protest outside the Commons all day Monday to persuade MPs to back the amendment which would have protected grants.

In the vote 31 Labour MPs disregarded the three line whip and voted against the government. A further 15 abstained.


[ image: David Blunkett called the Opposition arguments
David Blunkett called the Opposition arguments "utter cant"
The rebels, described by a government spokesman as "the usual suspects", were also angry about the proposed introduction of tuition fees, but did not get to vote on the issue as the debate ran out of time.

The Bill, which sets up General Teaching Council to boost standards of teaching, is part of the Prime Minister's drive to fulfil his election promise to back "Education, education, education."

The peers' three unsuccessful amendments would have:

  • retained student maintenance grants for the poorest students;
  • transferred to the GTC from the Education Secretary powers to bar teachers over child protection concerns;
  • and extended to English and Welsh students at Scottish universities the exemption from paying fourth-year fees granted to Scottish students.

    As none of these amendments was put through, Mr Blunkett told the House that the Bill would ensure "equality of opportunity" where it previously had been denied.

    He told the House that, combined with the School Standards and Framework Bill, currently before the Lords, it would raise standards and provide a skilled and educated workforce, "ready to compete in a globalised market."


    [ image: David Willets, Shadow Education Secretary]
    David Willets, Shadow Education Secretary
    Despite criticism that failing to allow amendments to plans for the General Teaching Council was a missed opportunity to recognise teachers' value, Mr Blunkett insisted that it would provide teachers with professional pride.

    "We want to build consensus, provide for some continuity and give opportunities where they did not exist before," he said.

    Further measures

    The Bill covers a wide range of issues. These include a mandatory headteacher qualification and plans to ensure that teenage employees are allowed time off work to study.

    The Education Minister Kim Howells also outlined a new clause in the Bill which, backed by all sides, would clear up confusion over institutions names. The new Bill will prevent further education institutions from using the word "university" in their title when they were not entitled to.


    [ image: Phil Willis was dismissive of the Bill]
    Phil Willis was dismissive of the Bill
    Reaction The Shadow Education Secretary, David Willetts, claimed students had been "double-crossed" by the government. He said the NUS had backed the government at the last election on the basis that maintenance grants would go, but that tuition fees would not be introduced.

    He added the Bill would not provide a long-term solution for deep-seated financial problems in higher education.

    One Labour backbencher said he was "unrepentant" at having rebelled against the government on Monday night. Tam Dalyell (Linlithgow) urged ministers to ensure it would be clear to students that their fees were being spent on improvements to their places of learning.

    The Liberal Democrat spokesman, Phil Willis, said the fees issue was a "tax on learning". He particularly criticised the way the government had put the Bill through parliament:

    "Part Two of the Bill has been bulldozed through the House with an arrogant disregard for debate on principled objections," he said.





    Advanced options | Search tips




    Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©


  • UK Politics Contents

    A-Z of Parliament
    Talking Politics
    Vote 2001
    Relevant Stories

    08 Jun 98 | Education
    Concessions on fees as MPs prepare to rebel

    09 Jun 98 | UK Politics
    Chance to boost teachers 'wasted'

    09 Jun 98 | Education
    31 MPs rebel over student grants

    08 Jun 98 | UK Politics
    Labour revolt bigger than expected

    08 Jun 98 | UK Politics
    Government sees off Scottish fees challenge





    Internet Links

    Department of Education


    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.




    In this section

    Livingstone hits back

    Catholic monarchy ban 'to continue'

    Hamilton 'would sell mother'

    Straw on trial over jury reform

    Blairs' surprise over baby

    Conceived by a spin doctor?

    Baby cynics question timing

    Blair in new attack on Livingstone

    Week in Westminster

    Chris Smith answers your questions

    Reid quits PR job

    Children take over the Assembly

    Two sword lengths

    Industry misses new trains target