Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education



Front Page

World

UK

UK Politics

Business

Sci/Tech

Health

Education

Sport

Entertainment

Talking Point
On Air
Feedback
Low Graphics
Help

Monday, June 1, 1998 Published at 21:30 GMT 22:30 UK


Woodward sacks solicitor after 'guilty' allegations

Elaine Whitfield Sharp was one of Louise Woodward's staunchest supporters

Louise Woodward has fired solicitor Elaine Whitfield Sharp after allegations the lawyer told a police officer she thought the British au pair was guilty of killing nine-month-old Matthew Eappen.

News that the 20-year-old former au pair had sacked Ms Whitfield Sharp followed a news conference held by the Massachusetts police officer who arrested Woodward's solicitor for drunk driving last week.


BBC correspondent Philippa Thomas on the solicitor's dismissal
Sgt Randy Cipoletta said the solicitor had told him she had been driven to drink because she knew Woodward was guilty.

A jury convicted Woodward of second-degree murder last year, but Judge Hiller Zobel changed the verdict to manslaughter.

He sentenced her instead to the 279 days in prison she had served since her arrest in February 1997.

Both sides are now awaiting the outcome of an appeal on the case.

'She knows Woodward is guilty'


[ image: Sgt Randy Cipoletta claims the solicitor knows Louise is guilty]
Sgt Randy Cipoletta claims the solicitor knows Louise is guilty
Sgt Cipoletta told reporters the lawyer was having a hard time handling what she believed to be the truth.

Mr Cipoletta arrested Ms Whitfield Sharp on charges of drunk driving on May 22.

Speaking at the press conference, Sgt Cipoletta said: "Elaine Sharp stated to me that she was an attorney for Louise Woodward, and when she took the case, she believed that she was innocent.


Sgt Randy Cipoletta comments at the news conference
"And she knows that she is guilty and is having a hard time handling it."

Ms Whitfield Sharp has denied making the comments and has accused the trooper of harassing her. State police are investigating a complaint filed by the attorney.

But in a statement released after the conference attorneys Harvey Silverglate, Andrew Good and Barry Scheck said Woodward had accepted their recommendation "to immediately dismiss attorney Sharp as one of her counsel, and a letter of dismissal has been sent."

It added: "We do not believe that Trooper Cipoletta is an extortionist and a liar, any more than we believe that Ms Woodward is a murderer and a liar.

"The evidence of Ms Woodward's innocence, fully known and understood by attorney Sharp as by the three of us, is as compelling now as it was before attorney Sharp's arrest."

The three lawyers praised Ms Whitfield Sharp for her contributions to some of the scientific evidence in the first-degree murder case, and for her generosity in hosting the Woodward family after her release from prison in November.


[ image: Elaine Whitfield Sharp: gave Louise a home]
Elaine Whitfield Sharp: gave Louise a home
But they described her as displaying "an aberrant pattern of behavior." And they said they hope she will use a court-mandated program to address some of her problems.

Sgt Cipoletta has said he might take legal action if Ms Whitfield Sharp did not apologise to him for saying the statements attributed to her in the report were untrue and that he made sexual advances toward her.

Ms Whitfield Sharp, aged 44, has pleaded guilty to the charges and after paying a fine said she was "appalled" at the state trooper's claims.


Elaine Whitfield Sharp defending her friend earlier this year
She complained to the state police that Sgt Cipoletta propositioned her and taunted her for representing Woodward

"The statements attributed to me by the police are not true," she said in a statement.

Following her release, Woodward, from Elton, Cheshire, went to live with Ms Whitfield Sharp, who was born in Chester, but moved out several weeks ago, both sides have confirmed.



Advanced options | Search tips




Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©


Relevant Stories

02 Apr 98 | Woodward
Louise Woodward's day in court

29 May 98 | Americas
Lawyer denies she lost faith in Woodward





In this section

Woodward lied on TV, says baby's uncle

'Absolute child abuse' says Woodward detective

Panorama - Louise Woodward's exclusive interview

Woodwards cash in

If parents didn't do it, who did? - Woodward

Parents go back to court

US press slam Woodward

It's easier for Louise - baby's uncle

Louise's Panorama interview: What do you think?

Press restrained over Woodward's release