Page last updated at 11:36 GMT, Monday, 14 December 2009

Vietnam and the Vatican promote reconciliation

Vietnamese President Nguyen Minh Triet's visit last week to the Vatican was the first by a head of a communist country. Although tensions remains, the BBC's Nga Pham reports the visit has raised hopes of reconciliation between the two sides.

Catholic dignitaries at So Kien church, in the northern province of Ha Nam - 23 November 2009
Hanoi wants church leaders in Vietnam to follow its rules, not the Vatican's

On 23 November, around 100,000 believers gathered in a small town near Hanoi to celebrate the 350th anniversary of Catholicism in Vietnam.

That evening, a message by Pope Benedict XVI was read before a sea of flickering candles and pious eyes.

The Pope wrote that the jubilee was " a time for reconciliation", as well as of building "a just and fair society… through genuine dialogue, mutual respect and healthy collaboration".

The message of "reconciliation and hope" was a fresh sign of efforts to bridge the divide between the communist country and Catholicism.

It came after a period that saw large protests erupting in Hanoi and elsewhere in Vietnam to reclaim Catholic lands and properties seized by the communist government when it came to power.

Whose land?

Land remains one of the thorniest issues in the relations between the Church and the state.

The Vietnamese government maintains that all land belongs to the state and refuses to discuss "historical claims" dating back to colonial times.

The Vatican has shown very good will. But it (normalisation) also depends on the behaviour of the Vietnamese Catholic church
Nguyen The Doanh,
Former head of Vietnam's Religious Committee

The government has rejected requests to return the Vatican Ambassador's residence in Hanoi, a church in Quang Binh, central Vietnam, and most recently a seminary in Dalat in the Central Highlands.

The protests over the properties were dealt with promptly and harshly.

In a fast-growing economy like Vietnam, land, apart from its religious significance, can also have great financial value. That reason alone is enough to ignite resentment between local communities and the Catholic church.

Booming belief

Official ties between the two sides were severed in 1959, when the Vatican's ambassador was removed from Hanoi.

Since then, the bilateral relationship has moved a long way, with dozens of talks held in the last two decades.

And although the authorities maintain control over religious activities, Catholicism in Vietnam has recently flourished, with more churches being built and congregations growing.

Catholic iconography is freely on sale in every corner of the country.

Catholics outside a church in Vietnam
Religious belief is on the rise in Vietnam

With more than six million believers, Vietnam boasts one of the largest Catholic communities in Asia and the Vatican wants to maintain its influence in the country.

It also wants to be able to appoint priests without state involvement.

President Triet's 40-minute meeting with Pope Benedict XVI on Friday was hailed by both sides as a "significant step" towards normalising relations.

After the meeting, a statement said the Holy See "expressed the hope that outstanding questions may be resolved as soon as possible".

Rising hopes

There is widespread hope among Vietnam's Catholic community that after President Triet's visit Vietnam and the Vatican would normalise relations and that would help settle land disputes in a more acceptable manner.

They also hope that the Pope will pay a visit to Vietnam in the near future. Official diplomatic ties between the Vatican and Vietnam would help bring this about.

Bishop Peter Nguyen Van Nhon, President of the Episcopal Council of Vietnam, said in an interview with the Vatican's news agency Fides that the meeting between Mr Triet and the Pope could create a "useful exchange".

"Exchanging information leads to mutual understanding to bring promises and new hopes to Vietnam and to the Church," Father Nhon was quoted as saying.

Vietnam's conditions

However, Hanoi seems unhurried and may have more say in the matter than it used to.

The Holy See made it clear during an Ad Limina (reporting) trip by Vietnamese bishops last June that the Church does not wish to replace a responsible government. But it is not enough.

Vietnam wants ties with the Vatican for international recognition, but wants its church leaders to follow Vietnam's rules, not the Vatican's.

Celebrations of 350 years of Catholicism in Vietnam, 23 Nov, 09
Catholicism was established in Vietnam 350 years ago

As explained by Nguyen The Doanh, the former head of the Government's Religious Committee, a normal relationship can only be achieved when the Vietnamese Catholic church and the Vatican are "in sync".

"The Vatican has shown very good will. But it (normalisation) also depends on the behaviour of the Vietnamese Catholic church," he said.

"Unfortunately there are still some priests in Vietnam who don't think the modern, advanced way," Mr Doanh told BBC.

One of them is Father Nguyen Van Ly, a dissident who has been in and out of prison in the last 25 years and is currently serving an eight-year sentence for spreading anti-government propaganda.

Hanoi also issued warnings to some of the priests who backed the land protests in 2008 and 2009, including the Archbishop of Hanoi, Joseph Ngo Quang Kiet.

Observers also note another factor that officials in Hanoi may be considering: China's approach to its own Catholic church.

Among Asian countries, only Vietnam, China, Burma, North Korea and Malaysia do not have diplomatic relations with the Vatican.

Some believe that Hanoi, always careful not to offend its big neighbour, is reluctant to close any deal before Beijing at least makes some move in its relationship with the Vatican.

Print Sponsor

Religious tension mounts in Vietnam
30 Sep 09 |  Asia-Pacific
Vietnam Catholics lose appeal bid
27 Mar 09 |  Asia-Pacific
Catholics find more freedom in Vietnam
02 Feb 06 |  Asia-Pacific
Vatican ordains Vietnam priests
29 Nov 05 |  Asia-Pacific
Vietnam priest jailed for dissent
30 Mar 07 |  Asia-Pacific
Prayers and protests in Vietnam
02 Sep 08 |  Asia-Pacific
Holy row over land in Vietnam
26 Feb 08 |  Asia-Pacific
Vatican envoy visits Vietnam
15 Mar 99 |  Asia-Pacific
Country profile: Vietnam
14 Dec 11 |  Country profiles
Timeline: Vietnam
13 Dec 11 |  Country profiles


Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2017 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific