BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: World: Americas
Front Page 
Middle East 
South Asia 
From Our Own Correspondent 
Letter From America 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Saturday, 23 September, 2000, 03:03 GMT 04:03 UK
'Nuclear spy' case reviewed
Wen Ho Lee
Critics say Mr Lee was mistreated on racial grounds
The United States Attorney-General, Janet Reno, has ordered a thorough review of the Justice Department's handling of the case against an ethnic Chinese scientist who worked at the Los Alamos nuclear laboratory.

The man, Wen Ho Lee, was kept in solitary confinement for nine months on charges of spying for the Chinese but was released last week as part of a plea-bargain agreement.

Earlier President Bill Clinton said he had been "quite troubled" by the treatment of the nuclear physicist.

Anybody who looks at this case and doesn't know the circumstances of it is going to say, 'Why?' And I think that's what the president kind of naturally asked

Attorney-General Janet Reno
Mr Lee was released after pleading guilty to a minor charge of mishandling classified information.

Racial claims

An apologetic judge said at the time that the government's actions had "embarrassed our entire nation".

Mr Lee was initially portrayed as a spy for China, although these allegations were unproven and no formal espionage charges were ever filed.

As part of the plea bargain agreement, Mr Lee was sentenced to 278 days, one day less than he had already served.

The three-year-old case was marked by claims that the scientist was unfairly singled out for investigation because of his race.

Alberta Lee, daughter
Mr Lee's family has always maintained his innocence
After meeting Mr Clinton on Friday to discuss the case, Ms Reno said she had ordered the Office of Professional Responsibility - which investigates misconduct by Justice Department prosecutors - and Federal Bureau of Information agents to carry out a review.

Mr Lee had been charged with 59 counts of breaching national security at the Los Alamos nuclear weapons factory, and faced life in prison if convicted.


In exchange for his guilty plea 10 days ago, the government dropped 58 counts against him.

The federal judge in the case said he was also sorry that the plea deal prevented disclosure of information that would have shed light on the reasons for Mr Lee's detention.

Mr Lee lost his job at the laboratory against a background of widespread allegations that he had compromised what were described as "the crown jewels" of US nuclear weapons technology.

Ms Reno on Friday defended the decision to keep Mr Lee in solitary confinement because much of the case hinged on the whereabouts of seven computer tapes onto which the scientist had admitted downloading sensitive information.

As part of the proposed deal, Mr Lee agreed to co-operate with investigators as they try to confirm his account that he destroyed the missing tapes.

Asian-American leaders have demanded the White House appoint a special commission to investigate whether racism played a role in the treatment of the scientist.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

22 Sep 00 | Americas
US report admits racism
12 Sep 00 | Americas
Los Alamos plea deal delayed
18 Jun 00 | Americas
Los Alamos suspicions grow
23 Sep 99 | Americas
FBI relaunches nuclear spy probe
06 Aug 99 | Americas
Nuclear spy probe 'flawed'
23 Jun 99 | Americas
Senate slams nuclear lab security
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Americas stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Americas stories