BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC NEWS CHANNEL
Last Updated: Monday, 17 October 2005, 15:57 GMT 16:57 UK
Court rejects US tobacco appeal
The US was trying to use anti-mafia legislation to fine tobacco firms
The Supreme Court in the United States has rejected a government appeal to pursue a multi-billion penalty against tobacco companies.

The US Justice Department was seeking $280bn (160bn) in damages from firms it accuses of misleading the public over the dangers of smoking.

But the Supreme Court denied its request to overturn an earlier ruling.

An appeals court had barred the government from seeking damages under the anti-racketeering legislation.

Correspondents say the Supreme Court's decision is a major victory for tobacco companies. Their stocks rose sharply following the decision.


The firms had argued successfully that the anti-mafia legislation could not be used retroactively to fine them.

The appeals court ruled in February that this law only allows for forward-looking remedies designed to prevent future violations.

Companies involved in the case include Philip Morris, Altria, RJ Reynolds, Brown & Williamson Tobacco and British American Tobacco.

They have denied conspiring to mislead people about the dangers of smoking.

The appeals court reversed a decision by the trial judge, Gladys Kessler, who had concluded that the law does allow the government to seek money as a legal remedy for decades of alleged fraud.

The appeals court's ruling took away the Justice Department's biggest weapon in the landmark case, which was filed in 1999.

US revives $280bn tobacco claim
19 Jul 05 |  Business
US slashes tobacco trial penalty
08 Jun 05 |  Business
Why tobacco was seen as a racket
05 Feb 05 |  Business
Court rejects $280bn tobacco case
04 Feb 05 |  Business
$280bn tobacco trial under way
21 Sep 04 |  Business
US seeks $289bn in tobacco claim
19 Mar 03 |  Business

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific