BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC News in video and audio
Last Updated: Friday, 14 September 2007, 11:26 GMT 12:26 UK
Man to defy mushroom picking ban
Daniel Butler with a Porcini mushroom (picture: Daniel Butler)
Today it may be mushrooms, but tomorrow it will be blackberries
Daniel Butler
A fungi expert intends to defy a ban stopping people from picking mushrooms on a huge estate in mid Wales.

Daniel Butler has been showing paying guests around the Elan Estate since 1998, and regularly picks fungus.

But the Elan Valley Trust, which is responsible for its flora and fauna, said this week that some species were in decline and imposed the ban.

The trust's chairman described Friday evening's free public foray as "extremely irresponsible".

Meanwhile, the Countryside Council for Wales (CCW) said picking small numbers of fungus was unlikely to jeopardise the species, but it was advisable to seek the permission of the landowner.

Mr Butler said: "I'm challenging the ban because it has no scientific basis and is unenforceable in practice.

'Cashing in'

"If an activity is harmless and has been carried on for centuries why ban it now? Today it may be mushrooms, but tomorrow it will be blackberries and sloes."

He explained that some mushrooms were so small that the only way to examine them was by picking them.

John Evans, chairman of the Elan Valley Trust, condemned Friday's foray.

"Whether or not his proposed actions are legal, in my opinion it is extremely irresponsible for him to encourage an unknown number of people to embark on a mass foray.

Elan Valley
The Elan Valley is a special area of conservation

"However knowledgeable he may be personally about fungi, he cannot possibly instruct a mass of people on what they should or should not do."

The CCW said it was not a criminal offence to pick mushrooms growing in the wild.

A spokeswoman added: "While picking small amounts for your own use is often accepted custom, it is advisable, where possible, to seek the permission of the landowner.

"Picking a relatively small number of edible fungi in a responsible way is unlikely to jeopardise the presence of such fungi."

The estate's head ranger Peter Jennings said earlier this week that some people were "cashing in" by selling car boot loads of the mushrooms.

But Mr Jennings said there were no plans to erect warning signs on the 70 square mile (181.3 square km), 42,000-acre (16,997 hectares) estate which is in the counties of Powys and Ceredigion.

Reserve ban on mushroom picking
11 Sep 07 |  Mid Wales
Water museum reaches cash target
02 Aug 06 |  Mid Wales
Elan dam's centenary celebrated
18 Jul 04 |  Mid Wales
Trust takes on dam homes
19 Apr 04 |  Mid Wales


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific