Page last updated at 07:45 GMT, Friday, 17 July 2009 08:45 UK

Failures to 'join up' transport

First Great Western train at Paddington, London
Electrifying the London to Swansea line is a priority for the MPs

Important transport projects such as high-speed rail and road links between Wales and England are not being given enough priority, MPs say.

The Welsh Affairs Select Committee is calling for better co-operation between UK and Welsh ministers to create a joined-up public transport policy.

It also wants later timetabling of trains between south Wales and London to promote entertainment and tourism.

Both UK and Welsh governments say ministers are in close communication.

Rail Greater coordination of different rail franchises is needed. A failure to predict passenger increases, insufficient rolling stock and high peak fares is "highly disappointing". First Great Western - later timetabled trains to maximise entertainment, sport and tourism opportunities, while electrification should be a "priority"
Road Improvements to road networks are being held back by poor strategic project planning
Buses Anomalies between English and Welsh bus pass systems must be removed, particularly for those travelling longer distances
Air Many Welsh passengers fly from airports in England, either because of geographical proximity or because Cardiff does not serve the destination they need. Public transport links from Wales to Liverpool, Manchester and Birmingham airports "inadequate"
Source: Welsh Affairs Select Committee report

It suggested that high peak-time fares were discouraging people from leaving their cars at home.

Those passengers who did decide to take to the train found there was often insufficient rolling stock, especially at busy times.

Track upgrades

The committee said there had been only minor improvements to the service on the First Great Western main line, and the general level of service remained "unacceptable".

"If people are going to be persuaded to leave their cars at home and take public transport, then the services they use must be up to scratch," said the committee chairman, Dr Hywel Francis.

The committee's report on cross-border transport warned that important road links were not being funded as they were not a priority for English regions.

It also said trains were not good enough.

"Although we heard of some examples of good practice, for example in the north-east, too many opportunities for improvements are being missed."

Top of the list of priorities for the MPs is the electrification of the rail line between London and Swansea.

The committee said it would lead to significantly better services for passengers.

The report also suggested that later running of trains from south Wales would help promote entertainment and tourism in the area, something it said had been seen in cities like Bristol and in Yorkshire.

The DfT, the Welsh Assembly Government and local authorities on both sides of the border must review their priorities and ensure closer working
Dr Hywel Francis, MP

David Jones, the MP for Clwyd West, who is a member of the committee, said the freight industries in England and Wales currently operated as if they were in different countries.

"We were quite impressed with the Welsh road freight strategy. The difficulty is that it's not linked up with the English one," he said.

"And of course the big problem is that most heavy freight journeys either end or start in England.

"We are now arriving at the situation where the English department for transport and the Welsh Assembly Government are in some respects behaving as if they're in totally different countries and possibly in different parts of the world. And this is something we have really got to start addressing."

Both the Department for Transport (DfT) and the Welsh Assembly Government said rail transport was a vital issue for them.

"The government will be investing £15b in the rail network across England and Wales over the next five years, and we have been working closely with the Welsh Assembly Government to examine the detailed case for electrification of the Great Western main line between London and Swansea," said a DfT spokesperson.

'Closer working'

"We expect to make an announcement on this in due course"

But in their report, MPs were also unhappy at the way the DfT allowed regional authorities in England to take some decisions on road priorities.

It said it was not acceptable for the department to leave such matters to bodies with limited budgets and remits.

"The DfT, the Welsh Assembly Government and local authorities on both sides of the border must review their priorities and ensure closer working," added Dr Francis.

The committee was also critical of public transport links to major airport hubs, such as Birmingham, Liverpool and Manchester.


It said that cross-border traffic could also be reduced if Cardiff airport served more destinations.

Coldra roundabout
Plans for an M4 relief road and new Cardiff airport road have been dropped

However, the mention of Cardiff airport in the report will be contentious, coming just days after it was announced that plans for a new airport access road in the Vale of Glamorgan were being dropped.

The area's MP John Smith said the decision was "economic lunacy" and a "reckless decision for the Welsh economy".

The Deputy First Minister Ieuan Wyn Jones also announced on Wednesday that plans for a six-lane M4 relief road around Newport were being scrapped, after the cost rose to £1bn from its £340m estimate in 1998.

Responding to the MPs report, a spokesperson for the assembly government said officials and the Deputy First Minister continued to work closely with their UK counterparts.

"We also work closely with local authorities to improve planning and delivery of transport issues in Wales, for example in the development of the national transport plan," added the spokesperson.

Print Sponsor

Businesses' anger at M4 road loss
16 Jul 09 |  Wales
M4 and airport road plans dropped
15 Jul 09 |  Wales
Groups call for congestion charge
15 Jul 09 |  Wales politics
M4 relief road 'could open 2013'
20 Sep 07 |  Wales
6m park and ride scheme approved
06 May 09 |  Wales politics
Transport group's 350m blueprint
06 Jan 09 |  Wales

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2017 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific