Europe South Asia Asia Pacific Americas Middle East Africa BBC Homepage World Service Education

Front Page



UK Politics







Talking Point

In Depth

On Air

Low Graphics

Monday, August 16, 1999 Published at 22:57 GMT 23:57 UK

Special Report

"Make way for Welsh Tories" - analyst

Welsh politics must make room for the Tories, an analyst claims

The future of the centre-right is perhaps the most important question in Welsh politics today, according to a political commentator.

Simon Brooks, editor of the Welsh-language current affairs magazine Barn, has made a special study of Conservatism in Wales.

In his publication, Conservatism and the New Wales, he argues that the Tories' electoral failure in Wales has been due to their inability to establish a Welsh identity of their own.

"It is impossible to have a mature political system in any developed country without the willing participation of a sensible centre-right element," he says.

Mr Brooks says that in the wake of devolution, it is the "historic responsibility" of "Welsh patriots" like himself to help the Conservatives become a Welsh party, even if that means the centre-right would have more influence in Welsh politics than previously.

[ image: Former Welsh Office minister Sir Wyn Roberts]
Former Welsh Office minister Sir Wyn Roberts
He points out that many Welsh Tories, such as long-serving former Welsh Office minister Sir Wyn Roberts, have also been noted for their commitment to Welsh culture.

In addition, many grass-roots supporters of the Conservatives in rural Wales are also strong supporters of the Welsh-language culture.

However, he says, the fact that the Conservatives at a United Kingdom level had refused to question the former constitutional status quo meant that in Wales, they were doomed to be seen as the "English party".

Now that devolution is a reality, however, he says the Tories have been pushing harder than some other parties for the Assembly - whose creation they had opposed - to use its powers to the full.

[ image: Could Tories press for a federal Britain?]
Could Tories press for a federal Britain?
With UK party leader William Hague arguing that Welsh and Scottish MPs should lose their voting rights on English affairs at Westminster, then this could force Tories in those countries into a more revolutionary position - pressing for a federal Britain.

That would leave Labour upholding the present devolution settlement and consequently being identified in people's minds as the "English party", he says.

The public image is of Wales as a country with broadly liberal values - reflected in the fact that no Tory MPs were returned in the 1997 General Election. However, Mr Brooks argues that this actually conceals the fact that many Welsh political and cultural values are traditionally conservative.

[ image: Tory AM Glyn Davies]
Tory AM Glyn Davies
He says he sees this viewpoint reflected in the Assembly by "talented" Tories like Glyn Davies, Jonathan Morgan, David Melding and Nick Bourne.

He believes the bulk of the Tory members of the National Assembly would be open to such an approach, particularly following the departure of hardline British centrist Rod Richards as their leader.

With the advent of the National Assembly, the Tories now have a chance to harness what he calls: "a healthy-enough emphasis on the creation of wealth and respect for individual freedom; whilst still respecting the social contract that brings men and women together."

"We must all strive to ensure that those who hold this political viewpoint feel themselves to be a full and proud part of a Welsh civic community," he says.

Advanced options | Search tips

Back to top | BBC News Home | BBC Homepage | ©

Relevant Stories

11 Aug 99 | UK Politics
Bourne nominated for Welsh Tory leadership

02 Aug 99 | UK Politics
Labour warns of Tory 'extremism'

29 Jul 99 | UK Politics
Tories pledge to bring government to heel

15 Jul 99 | UK Politics
'English votes on English laws'

Internet Links

Conservative Party

National Assembly for Wales

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.

In this section

Released hostage returns home to Wales

Puma is 'definitely' on the loose

Stereophonics earn their rock stripes

Drug arrests mar jazz festival

Internet sex doctor banned

Welsh leader supports cannabis call

MP seeks solution to asylum tensions

Welsh Tories elect new Assembly leader

'Make way for Welsh Tories' - analyst

Inquest opens into tent fire death

Welsh pit stop for Formula Three

Church tackles genetic engineering

'Poverty pilgrims' begin march

Fear of threat to river pollution fight

Tories seek place in new Wales

From UK Politics
Welsh Tory attacks 'gagging attempt'