BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: UK Politics
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

The BBC's Political Correspondent, Mark Mardell
"Economists say these new figures are plausible"
 real 56k

The BBC's Carole Walker
"Labour are taking this very seriously indeed"
 real 56k

Monday, 30 October, 2000, 17:05 GMT
Portillo hints at 8bn tax cuts
Michael Portillo
Michael Portillo: Pledging to cut tax and increase spending
Shadow chancellor Michael Portillo has said the Tories could offer 8bn in tax cuts if they won the next general election by not increasing public spending by as much as Labour.

Labour immediately rebutted the claim, lining up a string of cabinet ministers to denounce the proposals as leading to privatisation of the NHS, describing them as presenting a "real and present danger" to the service.

In an article for The Times newspaper Mr Portillo sought to neutralise Labour's repeated accusations that Conservative spending plans amounted to 16bn worth of cuts in public services.

I'm talking about changing the way people think about the way they support the health service and take the strain off it wherever they can

Michael Portillo
Outlining his strategy on taxation Mr Portillo told the BBC it was time the public was told that spending on services could be increased by 60bn - compared to Labour's planned 68bn - as long as the economy was growing.

Labour spending 'unsustainable'

The shadow chancellor said he would not commit himself to a particular figure for tax cuts, despite telling The Times that cutting 8bn off the tax burden was a possibility.

He would have to find spending cuts to pay not only for his tax plans but also for the extra spending his shadow ministers are promising

Andrew Smith
Mr Portillo promised details on figures would be announced in the future, but the party would not go as far as releasing a shadow budget as Labour had done in 1992.

So far the Tories believe they have identified savings of 3bn from the social security budget and a further 2bn from efficiency savings.

Turning to Labour, the shadow chancellor said the government's plans to increase public spending by about 3% a year was unsustainable.

The Conservatives favour a figure of around 2%.

Tax protests

"What ever the government may be promising for public spending, which I believe is unsustainable - we can also see that people are now protesting about paying these levels of tax.

"They have protested over petrol and they are doing all they can - many people - to avoid paying tax on alcohol and cigarettes by buying them from car boot sales and so on."

He also stressed that the Tories would stick to Labour's spending plans for the first year after a general election.

Providing broad details of how to reduce public spending, Mr Portillo said people should be encouraged to spend more on their health and pension provision.

Tony Blair
Tony Blair attacked Tory spending plans at the Labour Party conference
Writing in The Times, Mr Portillo said: "If we were to commit ourselves to raise public spending by 60bn instead of Mr [Gordon] Brown's 68bn, and to make 8bn of tax cuts, we would, without any effect on debt, still be committed to a huge programme of spending that would easily encompass our commitment to match Labour's planned spending on the NHS."

During his Today interview, Mr Portillo harked back to his party conference speech by saying the Tories wanted to get "extra money from other sources" into the health service.

He said the Conservatives would expect "people who can, to make a little extra contribution".

Mr Portillo said: "I'm talking about changing the way people think about the way they support the health service and take the strain off it wherever they can.

'Privatisation and cuts'

Health Secretary Alan Milburn said this showed Mr Portillo had "once again confirmed the Tories' privatisation agenda for the NHS".

Leader of the House of Commons Margaret Beckett said the Tory plans were a "real and present danger" to the NHS, taking it back to a familiar agenda of "privatisation and cuts".

And Chief Secretary to the Treasury Andrew Smith said the shadow chancellor's policies threatened the health of the economy, consisting of "spending cuts he cannot name and tax cuts he cannot fund".

He said a Tory government would be have to borrow 11bn if it followed Labour's spending plans and met its own pledges.

"His shadow spokespeople in all the spending departments have gone around making additional commitments to Labour's spending plans, so he would have to find spending cuts to pay not only for his tax plans but also for the extra spending his shadow ministers are promising," Mr Smith said.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

03 Oct 00 | Conservatives
Portillo's symbolic speech
05 Sep 00 | UK Politics
Rivals take aim at Tory plans
03 Oct 00 | Conservatives
Portillo aims for private health boost
30 Oct 00 | UK Politics
Election campaign targets economy
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more UK Politics stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more UK Politics stories