BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC NEWS CHANNEL
Last Updated: Wednesday, 1 March 2006, 05:45 GMT
Labour MPs consider schools bill
Ruth Kelly, Education Secretary
Last night ministers met Ruth Kelly to express their concerns
Dozens of Labour MPs are considering whether to back the government's controversial Education Bill after its publication on Tuesday.

Last night 25 of them met Education Secretary Ruth Kelly to express fears it could lead to academic selection.

The bill allows schools in England to set up independent "trusts", with more say over admissions and budgets.

The Tories say the bill is "timid", but they will back it, while the Lib Dems say it is a "missed opportunity".

Concessions, such as banning interviews and a strengthened admissions code, have been included in the bill to win over Labour MPs who fear it will create a "two-tier" system and allow "backdoor" academic selection.

Parents, businesses and voluntary groups to be able to set up foundation (trust) schools, with control over budgets and admissions
Interviewing pupils and parents to be outlawed
Schools to 'act in accordance with' - rather than just 'have regard to' - admissions code
Schools to set up 'partnerships' with outside groups and 'federations' with other schools
Failing schools given one year to turn around or face being closed and replaced
30m for councils to raise standards

Councils will still be allowed to set up schools, which was something the government's original Education White Paper - published last year - had ruled out.

They will remain as a "strategic commissioner" for education in the area they cover, the bill says.

Ms Kelly says she is "confident" that her colleagues "should be able to unite around" the bill.

"It is a very good bill. It gives schools the freedoms they need to raise standards," she added.

But BBC political correspondent Carole Walker said many of the wavering Labour MPs who met Ms Kelly on Tuesday evening were not convinced by her reassurances.

Some were more likely to vote against the bill, rather than support it, she said.


Most computers will open this document automatically, but you may need Adobe Reader

Under the plans, failing schools would be given one year to turn around and, if there is no improvement in this time, could be closed, with a replacement school or academy opening on the same site.

Ministers are also promising 30m for local authorities to raise standards in weaker schools.

Private companies, charities, faith groups and parents will be given freedom to set up and run schools under the state system.

Existing schools will be allowed to develop "partnerships" with outside organisations and establish "federations" with neighbouring secondary schools.

The education secretary would retain a veto over councils' attempts to set up comprehensives, but would "not normally intervene".

'Back door' selection?

However, relinquishing the veto is one of the key demands of the rebels.

Ms Kelly said she would prefer the bill to pass with "the consent of my colleagues", rather than having to rely on Conservative support.

And the prime minister called the reforms a "defining moment" for the government.

Conservative leader David Cameron said he "would rather (ministers) didn't make concessions".

Liberal Democrat education spokesman Ed Davey told the BBC the bill had not dealt with "selection by the back door".

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific