BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC NEWS CHANNEL
Last Updated: Wednesday, 26 January, 2005, 11:25 GMT
CSA 'could close', says minister
Mother and children
MPs say it could take five years for the CSA to be 'fit for purpose'
Ministers would not rule out scrapping the Child Support Agency if it failed to improve, Work and Pensions Secretary Alan Johnson has warned.

But he said replacing the controversial CSA would be "the nuclear option".

A report by the Commons work and pensions committee called for the agency to be wound up unless it improved its service within weeks.

Chairman Sir Archy Kirkwood said: "If the agency cannot be rescued, then it must be replaced."

I certainly wouldn't rule out the nuclear option of moving to a completely new system
Alan Johnson

The committee reached its conclusions after it found that nearly 250,000 cases have yet to be processed.

It warned that it could be five years before the CSA was "fit for purpose", describing it as "a failing organisation" and "in crisis" with parents facing payment delays and inaccurate maintenance calculations.

The report urged the CSA to draw up contingency plans, including the "abandonment option", to be presented to Parliament by Easter, in case the CS2 computer system could not be made to work.

Needs convincing

And responding to calls for the agency to be scrapped, Mr Johnson told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "I certainly wouldn't rule out the nuclear option of moving to a completely new system.

"But I think the select committee would agree with me we would only do that when we were absolutely convinced that this system just isn't going to work."

The woeful record of the CSA is a shameful indictment of the government's priorities
Sir Archy Kirkwood

The MPs launched their inquiry into the CSA's performance after it became clear that, despite the introduction of a simpler system of calculating maintenance payments for new cases in 2003, a backlog of claims was building up.

The MPs found the 456m system from American IT giant EDS was "nowhere near being fully functional and the number of dissatisfied, disenchanted and angry customers continues to escalate".

Faced with the committee's criticism, the government has suspended its plan to cut the agency's staff by 25%.

The CSA has been surrounded in controversy since its introduction in 1993 to assess and enforce child support payments by absent parents.

Hot pursuit

It is currently chasing outstanding payments of more than 720m, while a further 947m has been designated as "unrecoverable".

At the end of the day I need that money desperately for my children - but I'm not holding out any hope
Michelle, mother of twins

Michelle, a mother of twins, said she had not received a penny of the 57 a week she should be receiving from her ex-partner and had faced an "on-going battle" with the CSA.

Her forms have twice been lost in the post, she said. "I don't receive correspondence, I don't receive phone calls, I have to chase them all the time," she said.

Theresa May, Tory shadow work and pensions secretary, said: "We have got to find a way that's going to ensure those payments get through to the people who are due them."

The agency's former chief executive Doug Smith quit last autumn claiming he was "seriously disappointed" with its performance.

The committee said the National Audit Office should investigate why the EDS system had gone so badly wrong.

It blamed the agency's senior management for a "multitude of problems" within the agency, including for an apparent lack of training of frontline staff.

Why MPs believe the CSA should be scrapped

The troubled history of the CSA
17 Nov 04 |  Politics
'Basically, it doesn't work'
17 Nov 04 |  Politics

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | World | UK | England | Northern Ireland | Scotland | Wales | Politics
Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health | Education
Have Your Say | Magazine | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific