Page last updated at 14:37 GMT, Friday, 6 March 2009

'I was blacklisted for speaking up'

By Victoria Bone
BBC News

Construction workers
Union say those who question health and safety can be targeted

An investigation by the Information Commissioner says it has uncovered a secret database of building workers.

The Commissioner says notes on individuals - including descriptions such as "ex-shop steward, definite problems" and "Irish ex-Army, bad egg" - were used to unlawfully vet job applicants.

The BBC News website spoke to two workers who say this alleged "blacklisting" is not new and can be very damaging.

It often happens, they say - and unions agree - to those who are simply trying to make their industry safer by raising concerns over health and safety.

Arthur McKevitt described his experience in 1987 when he lost a lucrative opportunity to work on the building of the Channel Tunnel because he had been blacklisted.

He said: "Half way through my induction one of the chaps in charge came over and said, 'You can't start today, you'll have to come back tomorrow.'

"I thought something wasn't right and the next day he said I couldn't work for them because I had been branded a troublemaker.

"The only thing I could think of was that a few years before I had a job in the north east of England and there were a lot of health and safety problems.

"There were a few arguments with the management over it."

'Disgusting practice'

Mr McKevitt, now 66 and living in Newry, County Down, refused to accept the decision.

It clashes with the rule of law
Arthur McKevitt, who was blacklisted

His data was being held by an organisation called The Economic League which gathered information on workers who could be deemed to be subversive or had particular associations such with the Communist Party.

Mr McKevitt attempted to sue The Economic League, but it placed itself into liquidation before the case came to court.

He was eventually able to clear his name, but suffered a lot in the meantime.

"It was very damaging to me," he said. "I lost a year and a half of work. I would say I spent 10,000 on the case, as well as all the lost wages.

"This is a disgusting practice. It clashes with the rule of law."

Roddy Kyle was another worker who believes he experienced blacklisting in the 1980s, again because he raised safety concerns.

He is a mechanical engineer, specialising in work on oil rigs, and his problems began after the Piper Alpha rig disaster in 1988 in which 167 people died.

"It was glaringly obvious that the platform had blown up due to very, very lax safety measures," he said.

"Piper Alpha was an accident waiting to happen and the majority of workers knew that, but they wanted their jobs as well. It was a very difficult time to get work so if you got a job you sat tight.

I've always raised real issues, not spurious ones
Roddy Kyle, engineer

"But I have always been very strong on safety. It's a dangerous industry and you have to keep your wits about you.

"So if there are any problems I've always been outspoken about them, but I've always raised real issues, not spurious ones."


In 1989, Mr Kyle, now 66 and living in Inverness, was involved in investigating several accidents on the Shell Tern platform in the North Sea.

Shortly afterwards he was told he was being replaced, supposedly because he "wasn't prepared to get on with fellow workers".

He was then moved to another platform - after fighting against a pay cut - where he again made complaints about health and safety.

Soon after that he was sacked - in his view because he had been branded as someone who would not keep quiet.

Mr Kyle took his case to an employment lawyer and eventually accepted a 10,000 settlement.

"It was a very difficult period, not one that I really want to remember," he said.

"It was common knowledge that blacklisting went on - companies want to be able to get to the end of a job and say it's been completed on time, on budget and without any safety incidents.

"But it's often not true, there are problems going on behind the scenes.

Really, in the 21st Century, do we need this sort of McCarthyism?
Alan Ritchie, UCATT

"The thing is you are not just putting your head above the parapet at one firm, you're doing it across the industry and you could be putting your whole future career at risk."

The Union of Construction, Allied Trades and Technicians (Ucatt), said many of its members, some of them designated onsite safety representatives, had been "victimised and dismissed after complaining and whistle blowing about dangerous sites".

General Secretary Alan Ritchie told the BBC: "Really, in the 21st Century, do we need this sort of McCarthyism?

"Simply because you were prepared to turn around and say, 'By the way, the health and safety in this site is a disgrace and there's got to be something done about it,' suddenly you find yourself never working in the industry for years."

Ucatt pointed out that construction is the most dangerous industry in Britain, with more than 70 deaths last year.

It says the use of blacklisting against those trying to change that could have serious safety implications.

Print Sponsor

'No decision' on giant database
17 Jul 08 |  Politics
Do you know what they know about you?
23 Nov 07 |  Technology

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2018 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific