BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC NEWS CHANNEL
Last Updated: Sunday, 29 July 2007, 00:43 GMT 01:43 UK
Web child fight videos criticised
Clips of fights that can be watched on the web
Many of the attacks are worse because the cameras are there
Police chiefs have urged websites to remove violent video footage of children fighting, following an investigation by the BBC.

Panorama found that films showing brutal fights between children are regularly uploaded to sharing websites.

Police say the companies should monitor what is posted on their sites and remove any violent or criminal content.

But YouTube, one of the sites found with footage, says it relies on users to "flag up" inappropriate films.

The investigation found films showing children as young as 11 and 12 punching and kicking other youngsters.

Brandishing handgun

One showed a youth brandishing a handgun and smashing it against a police car.

Another shows a laughing teenager jumping on a police car and shattering its windscreen.

Deputy Chief Constable Brian Moore, of the Association of Chief Police Officers, said it was the responsibility of internet companies to search their sites for videos of violence and crime.

Look all this is happening, this is real life, this is going on, we're going to show it
Hayden Hewitt

They should then pass the details to police.

He said: "They are responsible for what is on their products - they are making a profit from this.

"We would question who is in a financially better position to police the likes of YouTube - those in the private sector, who are earning huge amounts of money, or police forces which are currently having to stretch budgets."

But YouTube, said it did not employ anyone to police what is posted. The site, which is owned by Google, claims pre-screening content is a form of censorship which is not the role of a private company.

A spokesman said the website takes down videos but only if they are flagged by users and subsequently found to breach their guidelines.

Rule breakers

"Sadly as with any form of communication, there is a tiny minority of people who try to break the rules," the spokesman said.

"On YouTube these rules prohibit content like pornography or gratuitous violence. We don't want that sort of material on our site, and nor does our community."

Videos should not be policed by the website itself, it is a collective issue and we should all be involved
Mark, Basingstoke

The YouTube spokesman added the website would help police if they were approached for information.

Another website which features in the programme, Liveleak, said it checks all videos before hosting them.

Hayden Hewitt, co-founder of the website, defended the inclusion of such fights including one in which a girl had to go to hospital with a detached retina.

He said: "Of course it's horrible. It's not about me morally defending anything here.

"We have to take a stance of saying 'look all this is happening, this is real life, this is going on, we're going to show it."'

Panorama: Children's Fight Club will be shown on BBC One on Monday, 30 July at 2030 BST.

Who should police internet videos?
Service providers
Other body
7755 Votes Cast
Results are indicative and may not reflect public opinion

Man traced over web 'gun' videos
28 Mar 07 |  South of Scotland
'YouTube gangsters' spark inquiry
06 Mar 07 |  Merseyside
Anger over schoolgirl fight video
13 Sep 06 |  South East Wales
MP urges YouTube violence debate
19 Oct 06 |  Politics


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific