BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC NEWS CHANNEL
Last Updated: Tuesday, 29 November 2005, 11:37 GMT
Government sites 'fail disabled'
Almost every government website in Europe fails to meet basic standards for accessibility, a study shows.

The report by the UK Cabinet Office found that 97% of official sites were unusable by disabled people, largely because they ignored well-known techniques for making data accessible.

This is despite attempts by governments to put more services online.

The study found that the best stimulus to making sites accessible were legal penalties for non-compliance.

Poor performance

The report was produced by the e-Government Unit of the Cabinet Office.

It was released to coincide with the UK's EU Presidency and surveyed 436 public service websites across many European nations.

According to the study, 48.1% of Europe's population of 460 million people use the net and approximately 39 million people in Europe have some form of disability.

Many governments and public agencies have championed the net as a way for many disabled people to get at information and services they would otherwise struggle to access.

But the survey found that only 3% of the sites it looked at passed basic tests on accessibility set down by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C). These ensure that the data in web pages can be translated by software into a form usable by deaf, blind or otherwise disabled people.

The test regime involved checking the 436 sites using software utilities that look behind the scenes to ensure webpages match good practice as well as manual visits to ensure sites are easy to navigate around.

Of the 97% that failed:

  • 10% passed automatic checks but failed one or more manual checks
  • 17% failed automatic checks once or more
  • 70% consistently failed automatic checks

Common problems suffered by the poorly accessible sites involved insufficient use of descriptive tags to label images and other screen furniture to help software readers work out what they are.

Others failed to properly label frames to let software know what information a particular page held. Still others used invalid website code to create their pages.

Setting targets

The e-Government Unit report also found that there was no link between how sophisticated online services were and whether they met the accessibility standards.

It put forward a series of recommendations to help improve the performance of government websites.

It recommended the setting of a clear target for all government websites to meet basic W3C standards by 2010. It also said websites should be tested more regularly to ensure they comply.

It also said that studies should be carried out to see if it was worth creating a basic accessible website qualification to drive awareness of the issue.

The Royal National Institute of the Blind, AbilityNet, Dublin City University and Socitm Insight and the Royal National Institute of the Deaf collaborated on the survey.

Accessible coaches start trials
24 Nov 05 |  Technology
Pocket answer to digital divide
18 Nov 05 |  Technology
Smart card to open up computing
17 Nov 05 |  Technology
Travel industry ignores disabled
29 Aug 05 |  Business
Phone sites fail disabled surfers
11 Aug 05 |  Technology
Doubts cloud e-government sites
26 May 04 |  Technology

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific