BBC News UK Edition
 You are in: Talking Point  
News Front Page
N Ireland
Talking Point
Country Profiles
In Depth
BBC Sport
BBC Weather
Wednesday, 20 November, 2002, 14:03 GMT
Does broadband access matter to you?
Every school and doctor's surgery is to be wired up with a high speed link to the internet, Tony Blair has promised at a London internet summit.

More than 1bn is to be invested in giving broadband connections to public services like hospitals and universities who currently use telephone lines to access the web.

"Britain has the potential to become a technological powerhouse," Mr Blair said, while speaking of a government report that shows that the UK is the second best country in the world to do e-business - after the US.

The UK has been criticised for getting onto broadband so slowly and BT is expected to announce new ways to convince customers who are uncertain why they need broadband, to buy into it.

Does having broadband make any difference to you? Will the rest of the nation want it? Is it worth the money that the government is putting into it?

This debate was Your Choice. Every day until 29 November we are giving you the chance to help us set the debate agenda. Look out of this button on stories in our Technology Front Page:

Simply click on it and vote for the stories you want to debate. Want to know more about the Your Choice experiment? Click here.

This debate has now closed. Thank you for your comments.

By the time my rural town gets broadband it will be obsolete

Edward Conway, Northumberland, UK
Like many others I would love to be able to get broadband. BT have set a target of 400 users before enabling our exchange, at the moment we have 90 registrations. By the time my rural town gets broadband it will be obsolete. I wonder how many exchanges BT could have enabled with the money they've spent on advertising.
Edward Conway, Northumberland, UK

I live in a small village in Fife. The village is quite affluent, with a high proportion of computers per household, and a growing rate of usage amongst the OAP's. There is no Cable available here and most residents have to use BT as there is no real viable alternative. Our problem is that we are low in anyone's priority listing for Broadband, and we cannot come close to BT's demand for 400 interested users (there are not many more houses in the village). We cannot get any indication as to when BT will connect us up, and Blair's initiative will not help us either. We therefore believe that we will become second rate citizens.
Howard Williams, Fife, Scotland

If BT cannot supply the ordinary bod who wants it, how on earth are they going to supply it to anyone else? This will mean upgrading the exchanges that they don't want to upgrade for everyone else.
Robert, UK

I think it's a good idea, money well spent. Then again most systems will either end up as a grey sculptor in the corner of the doctor's surgery, or as a 20 kilo paper weight.
Steve G, Tyne and Wear, UK

The government should compel BT to make broadband available to all

Geoff Stafford, Manchester, UK
I can't believe the government is saying it will take until 2005 before only 90% of the county has the option of broadband. And BT is still pushing some second-rate 128k alternative that isn't always on. The government should compel BT to make broadband available to all and they should do it now. The UK completely missed out on the webcam phenomenon that preceded Big Brother and now we are set to miss out on the growth of online video.
Geoff Stafford, Manchester, UK

Investment in broadband for public services is an excellent way to cross subsidise universal access. It is a win-win situation - the public services get broadband, and people in areas with low population density will be able to connect without having to make ridiculous and humiliating petitions to BT. As for the need for broadband, the comments by Steve T provide the answer.
James, UK

We got broadband the moment BT made it an option for us and I would hate to go back to my old modem. The interesting thing is that our average monthly phone bill has gone down by 30 from two years ago, when we didn't spend half as much time online. Back then we also paid an additional 12 a month for our internet access. So for a monthly saving of 15 we now have a much faster connection, we can stay online 24 hours a day and we can use the phone while connected to the internet. It's a pretty good deal. Should the government spend our tax money on it? No! Spend that money on schools instead.
Christine, UK

Let's just get on with it

George Grant, England
I would sign up for broadband now if BT would supply it. Because we live in the country, we have no cable availability, so have to rely on BT. I think it is a disgrace that it is taking so long to roll out broadband. Let's just get on with it.
George Grant, England

Surely we need more nurses, teachers and doctors before spending a fortune on broadband, which at the moment only really serves to enable people to play games faster and download music.
Adam, UK

I would dearly love broadband but the cost is too much. It is around 27 pm on top of my local BT line charge (say 15pm) so overall it is much too much.
Lloyd, UK

I doubt the broadband revolution will catch on for mere mortals

Vicky, UK
I have been informed that due to certain aspects of my line (which is not my fault) even if I upgrade to broadband I will not be guaranteed the speed I am paying for. I would not mind so much, if it were not for the fact I am a full time carer to a disabled child. I rely on the net at the very least for email, news updates, and contact with family and friends. With modern sites being geared for fast connections I find many pages don't appear for a good four minutes if they don't time out. Also due to living in the sticks there are no alternatives like cable - so I sit, wait and hope, but I doubt the broadband revolution will catch on for mere mortals in the comfort of our own homes!
Vicky, UK

I would love to get a broadband connections. Unfortunately this does not appear to be possible where I live. Where's that you ask? Outer Hebrides? No I live in Hampshire! Incidentally we can't even get Channel 5 or terrestrial digital TV either.
Tim Lagor, UK

If broadband is available to patients in hospitals, I would like to see the scrapping of the expensive units currently housing a TV, radio and phone. Many people are so ill or haven't got the energy to read books or other activities that require high bouts of concentration, so TV is the only medium. Many people cannot afford 5 per day on these things and it should be free to use and they should only have to pay for the phone at normal BT rates at the end of the stay.
Helen, UK

Life without broadband would be unimaginable

Steve T, UK
Our business would be lost without broadband. With customers requiring large amounts of information transferred electronically, conventional modems would mean hours of line time, not to mention the cost! We can transmit drawings and other documents in seconds, paying a simple monthly charge. Our email is instant, and we can respond similarly. Life without broadband would be unimaginable for us. It is worth every penny paid for this service!
Steve T, UK

1bn isn't enough - the government should have spent the money it got from mobile phone firms to wire up every building in the UK.
Stephen, Wales

I seem to remember Blair making this promise before the 1997 election, and he didn't mention spending 1bn on it then - why has he not delivered before?
Ian, UK

The issue is totally irrelevant until broadband can be accessed throughout the whole country

Sylvia Foxcroft, England
It's all very well Blair saying that all this money is to go to schools etc for broadband access but what is the point of making this money available when a large part of the country cannot access broadband. I live in a rural area and the nearest town, which is only three miles away, has access to broadband (I use it at work) but although I have the same dialling code I can't access broadband at home. What Blair is saying sounds good, as ever, but totally irrelevant until broadband can be accessed throughout the whole of the country.
Sylvia Foxcroft, England

Giving broadband to local GPs would be like giving a laptop to a llama, they wouldn't know what is was for. Although commercial organisations can send me e-mails on my birthday, the anniversary of buying my car or the anniversary of buying contact lenses, my local GP refuses to take requests for repeat prescriptions by e-mail because "it confuses old people". Broadband will be wasted on the NHS and GPs until they abandon their patronising cottage industry mentality. Save us millions of pounds by spending it somewhere where it will be used wisely.
Richard, Northants, UK

See also:

18 Nov 02 | Technology
Links to more Talking Point stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Talking Point stories

© BBC ^^ Back to top

News Front Page | World | UK | England | N Ireland | Scotland | Wales |
Politics | Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology |
Health | Education | Talking Point | Country Profiles | In Depth |