BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC NEWS CHANNEL
Last Updated: Wednesday, 7 December 2005, 11:57 GMT
Power line 'key for green energy'
Pylon
The power line plans have brought local opposition
Failure to build a controversial new power line could kill Scotland's renewable energy plans "stone dead", green businesses have warned.

Opponents of the line said the larger pylons would ruin the landscape.

But industry forum Scottish Renewables said the 137-mile Beauly to Denny upgrade was necessary for the future growth of green energy production.

Scottish and Southern Energy has lodged a planning application for the new electricity transmission line.

It said that the current 132 kilovolt (kV) line would not be sufficient to feed power from the growing number of wind and hydro energy sites in the Highlands and islands to the National Grid.

This upgrade to the power infrastructure is as fundamental to the economy as our road or rail infrastructure
Maf Smith
Scottish Renewables

The 400kV upgrade plan consists of 600 electricity pylons between Beauly in the Highlands and Denny, near Falkirk, running through the Cairngorms National Park and within sight of the Wallace Monument in Stirling.

The larger pylons would reach up to 65m high, although there would be 200 fewer than at present.

Outdoor groups and local protesters have called for the transmission line to be buried underground, but SSE claimed the cost implications would be too high.

And Maf Smith, chief executive of Scottish Renewables, said that if work on the power line did not go ahead Scotland's renewable energy industry would be "strangled at birth".

He said: "We believe that Scottish and Southern Energy has put forward a robust proposal that minimises impact to an acceptable level and is a vital improvement on the existing line it will replace.

'National strategy'

"This upgrade to the power infrastructure is as fundamental to the economy as our road or rail infrastructure and future investment in renewables is dependent on this outcome."

Peter Pearson, secretary of Stirling Before Pylons, said: "There still isn't an overall energy strategy for Scotland.

"SSE haven't carried out a strategic environmental assessment which is required under European legislation, and which is currently going through the Scottish Parliament, to justify infrastructure proposals like this.

"Without a national strategy we don't think this line is justified."

Maf Smith clearly does not have a house under a pylon or children playing next to one
Brain Monteith
Independent MSP

Another protester, Caroline Paterson, said: "There is nothing green or sustainable about an increased number of children with leukaemia.

"The SSE's Dr Keith MacLean said health had not been a consideration in the routing of this line."

Independent MSP Brian Monteith, who has protested against the pylons, said: "Maf Smith clearly does not have a house under a pylon or children playing next to one.

"There is clear and unequivocal evidence that pylons are a danger to health and if this grid is to go ahead, all we are asking is that it should be put underground."

Scottish Renewables represents 160 green businesses and organisations.

The plans for the power line, being considered by the Scottish Executive, are out for public consultation until 12 December.


VIDEO AND AUDIO NEWS
Hear the argument from green businesses



SEE ALSO
Pylons plan 'most extensive ever'
03 Oct 05 |  Scotland
Pylon planning move sparks anger
29 Sep 05 |  Scotland
Pylons protest goes to landmark
23 Aug 05 |  Scotland
New power pylon route published
25 Jul 05 |  Scotland

RELATED BBC LINKS

RELATED INTERNET LINKS
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



FEATURES, VIEWS, ANALYSIS
Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit

PRODUCTS & SERVICES

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific