BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC NEWS CHANNEL
Last Updated: Wednesday, 1 October, 2003, 13:40 GMT 14:40 UK
MMR legal bid blocked
MMR jab is highly controversial
Campaigners have had to shelve plans for legal action over the controversial measles, mumps and rubella vaccine.

The High Court was due to hear the cases of more than 1,000 children who developed medical problems their parents believe were linked to the jab.

But the campaigners were unable to overturn a decision to deny them legal aid.

Most scientists believe the vaccine is safe despite fears of a link to autism and bowel disorders.

The decision will only confirm the view that the combined powers of government and drug companies are working against vaccine victims receiving justice
Jackie Fletcher
Several high profile studies have found the vaccine to be safe, and no research has been produced prove that the vaccine poses a genuine threat to health.

Supporters of the vaccine are angry that negative publicity has led to a signficant drop in the numbers of children receiving it, arguing that low immunisation rates increase the risk of a measles epidemic.

An independent funding review committee upheld a decision taken by the Legal Services Commission (LSC) that in the absence of any scientific proof that the vaccine was dangerous, the legal action - against the drug companies who manufacture the vaccine - stood little chance of success.

The LSC said it would be wrong to spend 10m of public money pursuing the cases.

The children involved in the court cases suffered disabilities such as autism, bowel problems, epilepsy and other learning difficulties.

JABS, which supports parents of vaccine-damaged children, described the decision to deny legal aid was "illogical, perverse and not in the public interest".

National co-ordinator Jackie Fletcher said: "The decision to halt the cases now, following the provision of new evidence in support of the children's cases, will only confirm the view that the combined powers of government and drug companies are working against vaccine victims receiving justice."

Vital cases

Ms Fletcher's 11-year-old son had the MMR jab and developed epilepsy and other problems afterwards. She believes that the triple vaccine caused the health problems.

She added: "These families believe their children are vaccine-damaged and need to know why their children's lives changed so dramatically within such a short time of the MMR vaccine being given if it wasn't the vaccine.

"The MMR court cases were vital not only to the families involved in the pursuit of justice for their children, but for all parents who are concerned about whether the vaccines they are giving their healthy children are safe."

This litigation is very unlikely to prove their suspicions
Clare Dodgson
Ms Fletcher said the UK's vaccine damage compensation scheme was wholly inadequate.

Solicitors Alexander Harris, representing the families involved in the MMR battle, expressed disappointment at the ruling.

A spokesman said: "We have been fighting these cases for a number of years and despite many difficulties the evidence has continued to strengthen - and has the support of the international team of experts advising us in the cases.

"We strongly believe in these cases and will be doing our utmost to continue to move this litigation and the issues forward."

Long shot

Clare Dodgson, LSC chief executive, said: "I appreciate that this decision will come as a great disappointment to the parents involved.

"I sympathise with their situation. Their children are clearly ill and they genuinely believe the MMR vaccine caused their illnesses.

"However, this litigation is very unlikely to prove their suspicions.

"It would be wrong to raise their hopes unreasonably by proceeding with this litigation."

The LSC has already spent 15m on research into the cases. This would now be submitted to the Medical Research Council, who are looking at the causes of autism.

The Department of Health said they hoped the LSC's decision would "draw a line" under the MMR issue.

A spokesman said: "We want to see parents given the facts about MMR - that there is no credible scientific evidence showing an association between MMR and autism."

"It remains the best form of protection for your child."

The BBC's Gareth Furby
"So far, research has failed to prove evidence of a link [between the MMR vaccine and autism]"

Mothers lose MMR battle
30 Jul 03  |  Health
Autism cases 'levelling off'
22 Jul 03  |  Health
MMR uptake falls to record low
26 Sep 03  |  Health
MMR research timeline
13 Jun 03  |  Health

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | World | UK | England | Northern Ireland | Scotland | Wales | Politics
Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health | Education
Have Your Say | Magazine | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific