BBC Homepage World Service Education
BBC Homepagelow graphics version | feedback | help
BBC News Online
 You are in: Health
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Background Briefings 
Medical notes 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

The BBC's Richard Hannaford
"Each claim takes on average 5 years before it is settled"
 real 56k

Clinical negligence lawyer Paul Balen
"What we should be concentrating on are the high incidents of negligence"
 real 28k

David Davis Conservative MP
"We are in a compensation culture"
 real 28k

The BBC's Jon Manel
speaks to Jane Chapman, Head of Claims Manager for North-West London Hospitals Trust
 real 28k

Wednesday, 2 May, 2001, 23:28 GMT 00:28 UK
NHS negligence claims soar
Surgeons carrying out an operation
There are 23,000 outstanding claims
The cash-strapped NHS is facing clinical negligence claims totalling 3.9bn - 10% of a single year's budget.

Claims settled in the last financial year totalled 386m, a staggering seven-fold increase over the last three years.

The increasing payouts are "spiralling out of control", says David Davis MP, who chairs the Commons public accounts committee.

The figures, presented to Parliament on Thursday, reveal that by March 2000, there were 23,000 legal claims against the NHS outstanding - totalling 2.6bn.

Predicted, but as yet unreported claims are estimated at a further 1.3bn - leaving the NHS facing total liabilities of 3.9bn.

Legal costs outstrip actual compensation in a large number of cases, the report says.

The only people winning from the system are the lawyers

David Davis MP, public accounts committee chairman

Mr Davis said: "This report demonstrates in the starkest terms that the current system for handling claims for clinical negligence in England fails to provide satisfaction to the patient or value to the taxpayer.

"The report provides firm evidence that the only people winning from the system are the lawyers.

"In almost all cases the taxpayer foots the bill, either in damages or in legal aid."

It also found that five-and-a-half years was the average time taken to settle claims, although children left severely handicapped and brain damaged after birth have to wait even longer for vital compensation.

Arnold Simanovitz, from the organisation Action for the Victims of Medical Accidents, said: "This compensation is not a bonanza for these patients.

"It is money they desperately need in order to restore some quality of life that they have lost because of mistakes made in the NHS."

Further improvements

The National Audit Office (NAO), which issued the report, said the four bodies involved in medical negligence claims - the Department of Health, the NHS Litigation Authority, the Lord Chancellor's Department and the Legal Services Commission - have made improvements but could make further changes.

NAO head Sir John Bourn said: "The present system is a slow and inefficient way of resolving small and many medium size claims.

"The Litigation Authority and the Legal Services Commission are making improvements to the way they handle claims.

"Implementation of our recommendations should provide patients with improved access to remedies, speed up settlements and cut legal costs."

The NAO's said change was needed to bring the system under control.

David Davis
Committee chairman David Davis: system is out of control

It suggests the NHS Litigation Authority, the centralised body set up to administer the claims, should draw up an action plan with targets and performance measures to address claims which have been underway for more than five years.

It also wants the progress of cases over five years old to be monitored, and steps taken to bring them to a timely conclusion.

The NAO wants the Department of Health and Lord Chancellor's Department to further investigate alternative ways of dealing with small and medium sized claims.

Non-financial remedies such as mediation could be offered.

Search BBC News Online

Advanced search options
Launch console
See also:

19 Jan 00 | Health
Litigation: Next NHS crisis
07 May 99 | Health
Negligence timebomb for NHS
18 Mar 99 | Health
Huge rise in GP negligence claims
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Health stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Health stories