Page last updated at 12:15 GMT, Monday, 24 November 2008

Are 'deluxe' albums fair to fans?

Leona Lewis
Leona Lewis has seen her debut album return to the top of the chart

By Andy Dangerfield
Entertainment reporter, BBC News

A "deluxe edition" of Leona Lewis's album Spirit has stormed into the chart at number one. But are fans getting value for money from these special releases?

Girls Aloud and Duffy are also releasing special versions of their albums, containing anything from unreleased interviews and demos to bonus DVDs, as Christmas approaches.

Girls Aloud
Girls Aloud's box set will contain unreleased demos and interviews
But should fans be expected to spend 15.79 (recommended retail price) again on the same material to get the extras?

"It's a two-finger salute to the loyal 200,000 fans who raced out to buy the original in its first week," says Yahoo! Music's chart expert James Masterton.

"Fans are being punished. If you bought the original, you'd feel incredibly stupid. If only you'd put your money in the bank and spent it now."

'New stuff'

The original version of Leona Lewis' Spirit has been bought by more than two million people in the UK since its release just over a year ago.

Now the repackaged release contains the same tracks as the original, but also has three new songs and a bonus DVD.

So what should people do with the CD they have already bought?

"Keep it!" said Leona Lewis in a recent BBC interview.

"The new stuff will be available on iTunes if they just want the songs."

But her cover of Snow Patrol's Run is not available as a single download until 1 December, two weeks after the deluxe edition album's release.

And fans miss out on receiving new artwork and the "making of" Forgive Me video, unless they buy the new version.

But Sony BMG says: "Deluxe editions are being led by fan demand."

"Leona hasn't done much new material in the last year. But there is a real hunger for new tracks from her."

'Bizarre situation'

Britney Spears
Britney Spears' special edition of Circus will include a bonus DVD
So why has the music industry fallen in love with deluxe versions of albums?

The recent trend dates back to last year's special edition of Amy Winehouse's Back To Black, which contained live songs and her cover of The Zutons' Valerie.

"You had the bizarre situation of the limited edition charting at one position and the other version charting at another," the Entertainment Retailers Association's Kim Bailey says.

Record labels cottoned onto the wheeze and chart rules were relaxed in September, allowing deluxe and original versions of an album to count towards the same chart position.

Rihanna's Good Girl Gone Bad deluxe edition, which came out in June, also attracts the ire of Yahoo!'s Masterton.

Released more than a year after the original, which sold more than a million copies, the Reloaded edition had new artwork and three new tracks.

"Rather than getting her to record a new album, they just tacked tracks onto the back of the old album and re-released it," he says.

Universal UK's commercial director, Brian Rose, says: "If an artist brings incredible new content to us, we reserve the right to put it out and give the consumer more choice."

But he adds: "We will always aim to release the deluxe edition date on date with the standard edition."

Alternative approaches

Coldplay are releasing an EP as well as a special edition album
Many artists are doing just that - releasing deluxe and standard editions of their latest albums on the same date.

Beyonce and Dido released different versions of their new albums last week and two editions of Britney Spears' Circus will be available from 1 December.

Some artists are taking alternative approaches.

Bloc Party released a digital edition of their new album Intimacy in August. Fans could pay 5 for the digital version or 10 to receive the digital version immediately and an extended version through the post two months later.

And Coldplay are releasing an EP, Prospekt's March, containing unreleased material from recordings for their latest album Viva la Vida.

Faced with a changing music market, labels are experimenting with different formats as they battle to win over record buyers.

Are deluxe editions here to stay? In the long run, fans will decide with their wallets.

Print Sponsor

Lewis beats Dido to UK number one
23 Nov 08 |  Entertainment
Leona rounds off an amazing year
07 Nov 08 |  Entertainment
Leona album smashes into US chart
17 Apr 08 |  Entertainment
Pop divas enjoy chart dominance
09 Nov 08 |  Entertainment
Winehouse tops album chart again
02 Mar 08 |  Entertainment
Winehouse and Lewis head charts
31 Dec 07 |  Entertainment

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Sign in

BBC navigation

Copyright © 2017 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.

Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific