BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC NEWS CHANNEL
Last Updated: Tuesday, 24 February, 2004, 12:51 GMT
Finding Nemo 'copy' case begins
Finding Nemo
The Disney cartoon has broken box office records
US studio Disney has defended itself against accusations it copied ideas from French author Franck Le Calvez in its hit film Finding Nemo.

The author's publishing house has applied for an injunction to stop Disney distributing Nemo merchandise.

Mr Le Calvez registered Pierrot the Clown Fish in 1995 but Disney lawyers Nemo's likeness could not be considered a brand in its own right.

The judge will rule on the injunction request on 12 March.

Judge Louis-Marie Raingeard de la Bletiere was shown extracts from the cartoon by Disney in a side room of the court chambers in central Paris.

He was also shown merchandise including cuddly toys, water pistols and colouring books submitted as evidence by both sides.

Finding Nemo
Finding Nemo is nominated for the Best Animated Feature Oscar

Lawyers for marine life enthusiast Mr Le Calvez said he registered an outline of his clown fish character with the French authors' copyright association in 1995.

His illustration of Pierrot was registed as a trademark for Flaven Scene publishing house in February 2003.

Disney's lawyers said Walt Disney Productions and animation studio Pixar thought up the idea of Nemo and registered their copyright as early as 2000.

"The trademark registered by Flaven Scene was a judicial manoeuvre," said Thierry Mollet-Vieville, a lawyer for Disney.

Mr Le Calvez's book was first published in November 2002 and sold its first print run of 3,000 copies.


But its second edition a year later sold hardly any copies as many bookshops did not want to stock it alongside Disney's Nemo books, published in France by Hachette.

"This is precisely the kind of case where our French legislation protects us against globalisation," said Marie-Catherine Brocherieux, one of Mr Le Calvez's lawyers.

"We have fought back because we are the ones who have been copied," she said.

A lawyer for Hachette said it could lose 700,000 euros (470,000 or $880,000) from a ban on sales of Nemo books in France between now and the civil trial, which is due to begin in November.

The lawyer added that Flaven Scene had refused to put up guarantees it could repay that amount if it lost the case.

Finding Nemo, about a fish searching for his missing son, was the biggest US film at the box office in 2003 and has made $850m (450m, 675 million euros) in ticket sales so far.

Nemo animator's fishy tale
31 Jan 04  |  Tees
Disney loses top cartoon deal
30 Jan 04  |  Business
Finding Nemo case delayed
29 Jan 04  |  Film


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | World | UK | England | Northern Ireland | Scotland | Wales | Politics
Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health | Education
Have Your Say | Magazine | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific