BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC NEWS CHANNEL
Last Updated: Monday, 5 April, 2004, 19:07 GMT 20:07 UK
Paddington crash firm fined 2m
Paddington crash at Ladbroke Grove
Hundreds were injured and 31 died in the crash at Ladbroke Grove
Thames Trains has been fined a record 2m over the Paddington rail crash in which 31 people died.

Its train passed a red light in 1999 at Ladbroke Grove in west London colliding with a First Great Western train.

An Old Bailey judge said the firm had not taken an "achievable step" to limit the risk of a crash, by ensuring the driver was properly trained.

The firm had admitted two breaches of health and safety law at London's Bow Street Magistrates Court in January.

On Monday Justice Rodger Bell told the court he was satisfied it was not the case that Thames Trains had put profits before safety.

But he said the company should have been aware there was a problem with the signal at Ladbroke Grove and made "serious omissions" in its driver training.

I share a sense of personal failure with many in the industry
Martin Ballinger
Thames Trains chairman

Handing down the 2m fine - the highest awarded in an HSE case - the judge said he had reduced the fine by a third to take the company's guilty plea into account.

Thames Trains chairman Martin Ballinger accepted the judgement, and admitted the accident was foreseeable and preventable.

"Thames recognises that the value of the fine is irrelevant to the grief and suffering of the bereaved and injured.

"I share a sense of personal failure with many in the industry.

"No words can adequately express the heartfelt anguish and sorrow felt throughout Thames Trains for the devastating consequences."

Unlimited fine

Relatives of those who died in the crash welcomed the decision.

Denman Groves, who lost his daughter Juliet, said: "I think it was a fair judgment."
22.3m - paid out in compensation to victims and their families in the 2001 Selby rail crash
1.5m - paid out by Great Western Trains Company Ltd following the 1997 Southall rail disaster in west London
550,000 - to each relative of the 170 victims who died in the 1989 Lockerbie air disaster

After the judgement there were calls for the money to go to survivors, rather than to the Government.

No individual members of Thames Trains were prosecuted by the HSE but the firm could have faced an unlimited fine.

Great Western Trains Company Ltd was fined 1.5m after being prosecuted under the act following the 1997 Southall rail crash in west London in which seven people died.

On Monday, Hugh Carlisle QC, prosecuting, said driver Michael Hodder had not been warned about an "infamous" signal in the Paddington area.

He told Mr Justice Bell: "If he had been properly trained, properly warned, driver Hodder would have paid greater attention to the signal and the collision would have been avoided.

This is a company which had a positive safety culture and record, and one which had displayed useful innovation in safety matters
Anthony Seys Llewellyn QC

The signal, which was "part of one of the most dangerous combinations of signals in the national rail network", had featured in a Railway Group Safety Performance Report of signals most frequently passed at danger, Mr Carlisle said.

"The collision was on a massive scale with devastating damage causing great loss of life and injury."

Anthony Seys Llewellyn QC, defending Thames Trains, said the company had never tried to avoid its responsibilities in relation to the crash.

"This is a company which had a positive safety culture and record, and one which had displayed useful innovation in safety matters," he told the judge.

The BBC's Tom Symonds
"The huge fine reflected the scale of the disaster"

Paddington crash survivors marry
14 Feb 04  |  England
Pay-out for rail crash victim
24 Nov 03  |  Berkshire
Pam Warren: Life after Paddington
06 Jun 02  |  UK Politics


The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites


News Front Page | World | UK | England | Northern Ireland | Scotland | Wales | Politics
Business | Entertainment | Science/Nature | Technology | Health | Education
Have Your Say | Magazine | In Pictures | Week at a Glance | Country Profiles | In Depth | Programmes
Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific