BBC Home
Explore the BBC
BBC News
Launch consoleBBC NEWS CHANNEL
Last Updated: Tuesday, 4 July 2006, 12:03 GMT 13:03 UK
'Clever' answer loses pupil marks
Many independent schools say GCSEs do not stretch the brightest
An "excellent" GCSE student had a mark taken away for giving an answer which a teacher said was "too sophisticated".

Katie Merchant, 16, of Brighton College, missed a "key word" in a Latin mock exam, although she showed more than enough knowledge for a full mark.

Headmaster Richard Cairns said the OCR exam board's assessment scheme, which the school used, was "too mechanistic".

An OCR spokeswoman denied bright pupils were held back and said the system was intended to be fair to all.


Mr Cairns said marking schemes - which tells an examiner how many marks to allocate for the various elements of an answer - "frustrated" bright pupils.

He is reducing the maximum number of GCSEs a pupil at the independent school can sit from 11 to nine, to free up more time for "critical thinking".

It's like encouraging children to dig up roads when they could be designing bridges
Richard Cairns, head teacher

Mr Cairns said: "The teacher had to take a mark away from Katie even though her answer was excellent.

"We have to follow the exam board's guidelines but it's all so mechanistic."

Katie was still awarded a top A* grade, but Mr Cairns said: "There's no room for individuality. It's like encouraging children to dig up roads when they could be designing bridges."

An OCR spokeswoman said that, as the board had not looked at the school's marking of Katie's paper, she could not comment on the particular case.

She added: "OCR's mark schemes are there to ensure that all candidates receive a fair mark for their work.

"Candidates will always receive credit for answering a question well and our mark schemes do not hold back brighter students."

See Katie Merchant's reaction to her lost exam mark

A-levels and GCSEs 'need review'
28 Jun 06 |  Education
State schools' student share fall
21 Sep 05 |  Education

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Has China's housing bubble burst?
How the world's oldest clove tree defied an empire
Why Royal Ballet principal Sergei Polunin quit


Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific