BBC NEWS Americas Africa Europe Middle East South Asia Asia Pacific Arabic Spanish Russian Chinese Welsh

 You are in: Business
Front Page 
UK Politics 
Market Data 
Your Money 
Business Basics 
Talking Point 
In Depth 

Commonwealth Games 2002

BBC Sport

BBC Weather

Friday, 10 August, 2001, 04:12 GMT 05:12 UK
Dutch prostitutes fight for banking rights
Prostitutes in front of the ING logo
By BBC News Online's Emma Clark

The oldest profession in the world is pitting its girl power against one of the richest.

A foundation representing prostitutes in the Netherlands has filed a complaint against Dutch financial giant ING, because the bank does not allow them to open business accounts.

Rode Draad (Red Thread), as the foundation is known, maintains that ING and other Dutch banks fail to treat prostitution - which is legal in the Netherlands - as a proper profession.

It's not a moral judgement. Our decision is pure business

Peter Jong, ING
In an attempt to open up access for prostitutes to financial services, Rode Draad has filed a complaint with the Netherlands' Office of Fair Treatment, which deals with inequality issues.

"[ING] has refused to allow them business accounts and this is not equal treatment," Christie ten Broeke, a member of Rode Draad's board, told BBC News Online.

"Because most prostitutes are women, we have used this to make a complaint," she added, explaining that the Office of Fair Treatment only deals with issues such as race or gender.

'Not a moral judgment'

ING defends itself by saying that it has a policy of not doing business with the sex industry.

"It's not a moral judgement," Peter Jong, a spokesman for the bank, said.

Amsterdam's red light district
Despite being legal, prostitutes find it hard to take out a mortgage
"Our decision is pure business. It is too big a risk. The sex industry is not stable or transparent and it is difficult to calculate risk."

Prostitution was legalised in the Netherlands in 1815 under the French emperor Napoleon, who was governing the territory at the time.

In 1988 it was defined as a legal profession and prostitutes were permitted to join a trade union.

However, 13 years on prostitutes still have problems getting home insurance, mortgages, or indeed any financial service that requires them to state their occupation.

And yet, as self-employed professionals, prostitutes are required by law to pay income tax and contributions to a Dutch disability insurance fund.

Tax-deductible condoms

Currently, prostitutes face little difficulty opening private bank accounts - although ING has only recently allowed this - because they are not required to reveal their line of work.

ING Bank in the Netherlands
ING concedes it may have to change its policy if it loses

However, opening a business account is preferable as it presents certain tax advantages.

Prostitutes who can show that they earn business income can reclaim tax on expenses such as condoms and sex toys.

Being treated as a commercial customer also makes it easier for prostitutes to take out loans to improve their businesses.

Rode Draad, which represents about 20,000 prostitutes, filed its complaint - based on individual complaints from prostitutes - earlier this year.

Dirty money

Last week, representatives of the foundation, including Ms ten Broeke, attended a meeting at the Office for Fair Treatment with ING to discuss the issue.

"We met with an [ING] lawyer and another man whose function was not made obvious to us," Ms ten Broeke said, obviously irritated that the bank had chosen not to send any senior officials.

The tax people would be on them like ticks and fleas

Christie ten Broeke
Rode Draad

During the hearing, ING defended its actions by saying that the sex industry was not transparent enough and that financial relationships with prostitutes could make it vulnerable to money laundering.

But Ms ten Broeke responded that any prostitute paying in large amounts of dirty money would immediately arouse suspicion.

"The tax people would be on them like ticks and fleas," she said.

No sex please, we're international

ING is also concerned that dealings with prostitutes would not go down well with its other clients in countries that are "not as liberal as the Netherlands", said Mr Jong.

The Netherlands' other banking giant, ABN Amro, claims not to be so squeamish.

A prostitute is treated like a normal client, just a business woman.

Geert Pielage
ABN Amro

Geert Pielage, a spokesman for ABN Amro, told BBC News Online, "We don't exclude a group in advance."

The key issue is whether their activity is legal or illegal, he added.

"A prostitute is treated like a normal client, just a business woman.

"If she wants a financial relationship with us, we look over her business," he said, though he noted that the bank did not accept every application.

In Ms ten Broeke's view, however, Dutch banks are generally not so accommodating.

"Many institutions don't give [prostitutes] professional recognition," she said.

Decision due

The Office of Fair Treatment is due to make a decision on the case in a matter of weeks - by 24 September at the latest.

Although the Office cannot force ING to open up business accounts to prostitutes, its ruling would be influential and could set a precedent.

ING's Mr Jong concedes that the bank might have to revise its policy, if the ruling goes against it.

"It's hard to say if we would change our policy.

"There are a lot of famous judges and lawyers working at the [Office of Fair Treatment].

"It's not something we can do nothing about [if we lose the case], we would want to discuss it very thoroughly."

Such sentiments will no doubt cheer the Rode Draad camp, which is keen to forge a milestone on the road to commercial recognition for prostitutes.

And besides, whether the foundation wins its case or not, the publicity has been great, admitted Ms ten Broeke.

"We have had a little publicity to show what a totally ridiculous concept this is," she said.

See also:

30 Jul 01 | Middle East
More Iranian prostitutes murdered
14 Mar 00 | South Asia
Bangladesh says prostitution legal
21 Aug 00 | South Asia
Sex workers await court decision
18 May 01 | Business
Are women better investors than men?
02 Jan 01 | Business
Women-only bank in Gulf
Internet links:

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

Links to more Business stories are at the foot of the page.

E-mail this story to a friend

Links to more Business stories